HomeРазвлеченияRelated VideosMore From: WatchMojo.com

Top 5 Games Whose Metacritic Score Are TOO HIGH

2438 ratings | 149026 views
Top 5 Games Whose Metacritic Score Are TOO HIGH Subscribe: http://goo.gl/Q2kKrD // Have a Top 10 idea? Submit it to us here! http://watchmojo.com/my/suggest.php Metacritic has always been a wonky system for evaluating your games, and these right here are some of the best examples. Welcome to http://WatchMojo.com/ and today we’re counting down our picks for the Top 5 Games Whose Metacritic Scores ARE TOO HIGH! #5: Fable 3 #4: Batman: Arkham Knight #3, #2 & #1: ??? Special thanks to our user “Dan Paradis” for suggesting this topic using our interactive suggestion tool at http://WatchMojo.com/suggest Script written by Nathan Sharp Our Magazine!! Learn the inner workings of WatchMojo and meet the voices behind the videos, articles by our specialists from gaming, film, tv, anime and more. VIEW INSTANTLY: http://goo.gl/SivjcX WatchMojo's Social Media Pages http://www.Facebook.com/WatchMojo http://www.Twitter.com/WatchMojo http://instagram.com/watchmojo Get WatchMojo merchandise at shop.watchmojo.com WatchMojo’s ten thousand videos on Top 10 lists, Origins, Biographies, Tips, How To’s, Reviews, Commentary and more on Pop Culture, Celebrity, Movies, Music, TV, Film, Video Games, Politics, News, Comics, Superheroes. Your trusted authority on ranking Pop Culture.
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (1029)
Aadi Dude (4 days ago)
Too much love shown for GTA and other games in the comments. Let's raise the #MW3Squad
MajieB (17 days ago)
Put Red Dead 2 in there it controls like a trash bag
Renegado140 (1 month ago)
I strongly disagree with GTA IV, say what you will about GTA V, but GTA IV had more singleplayer content than GTA V offers and a lot of details that is missing in GTA V, despite the details that were added into GTA V. Crowbcat has a video with the comparisons. Also with Batman Arkham Knight, the game has issues with the batmobile sections, but overall the game was damn good, and deserved the score it got. The side missions were pretty good and the details in the world is something that should be mentioned, but of course you guys just go into any game, look at what people say, then you go with that instead of actually playing the games for yourself.
hey guys the metacritic guys are experts the best in this deal they are very hard ratings in all the games, and gta 4 is gold, was the revolution of ps3 .....dont comment of that...you are not experts guys
GixusGaming (1 month ago)
GTA 4 make gta top 1 because 3rd best game all of time
The life of Dan (2 months ago)
Your WORST list yet. Nonsense:
BIGBOY2000 (3 months ago)
WatchMojo...get the füçk out of here!!!
NyQuiiL Cold & Flu (5 months ago)
GTA 4 was trash and overrated
GixusGaming (1 month ago)
calm down dude gta 4 make gta best top 1 because gta 4 is 3rd best game and gta 5 make gta best top 1 too because highly copied
technical Baragav (5 months ago)
THE GAMER (5 months ago)
GTA 4 is great
Claudio Galvis (7 months ago)
GTA IV is so boring
GixusGaming (1 month ago)
calm down dude gta 4 make gta best top 1 because gta 4 is 3rd best game and gta 5 make gta best top 1 too because highly copied
Zachary Michaud (7 months ago)
Played both Fable 2 and 3 and I like 3 better because the final boss is an actual challenge (instead of a simple button press) and it had a very emotional ending (liek if u cri evry tiem).
E (7 months ago)
where is the freaking Celeste?????
Vj Ramkilawan (7 months ago)
GTA IV was excellent. #Top10WMListsWhileStoned
Dan Barone (7 months ago)
Downvote for GTA 4 as number 1.
happy lad (7 months ago)
*cough* Ocarina of time *cough*
johnkop4 (7 months ago)
Gta v
Michael Jacobs (7 months ago)
Games can have flaws and still be good. Who knew?
Justin Kim (7 months ago)
AQWBlaZer91 (7 months ago)
I think some of the Final Fantasy games like VIII, X-2, XII, XIII, XIV A Realm Reborn and XV should deserve the spot on this list.
Aderemi Porsche (7 months ago)
WatchMojo might as well have put BioShock Infinite on the list, given how much they and pretty much everyone love to rag on the game.
Jupiter32 (7 months ago)
Kingdom Hearts 2 had the best total score than Dragon Age
Garrus1995 (7 months ago)
I don't care what anyone says, GTA IV was a revolutionary masterpiece. It had easily the best narrative in the franchise (and perhaps one of the best in gaming in general), a huge and detailed world to explore, fun combat and some genuinely entertaining side characters. Yeah it was a little annoying to have to hang out with in-game friends and maybe the driving wasn't perfect, but when you look at the many, many things that game did right as opposed to what it did wrong, it's easy to see why a lot of people consider it one of the best.
All call of duty after 2011
Mark Ayers (7 months ago)
Fable 3 and Arkham Knight are two fantastic games. I still replay them despite completing them both multiple times.
Nathan Custance (7 months ago)
Arkham Knight was amazing.
Adam Meza (7 months ago)
u guys only got 5?
Sumit Paul (7 months ago)
Agreed with the GTA 4 thingy wholeheartedly. Basically, metacritic said GTA 4 is better than GTA 5 or any other game in GTA series (albeit 1 point difference but still). Then again, screw critics. They are hiring complete morons these days for that profession.
drunk guy (7 months ago)
I agree with fable 3. I still have all 3 games and 3 is meh at best. Some jokes but meh. GTA 4 I completed the main game and the expansion disc (you know lost and dammed/ gay tony) in 2 days another meh from me. Oh watching the tv was funny (prinsses robot bubblgum )
fishpop (7 months ago)
#5: Fable 3 #4: Batman: Arkham Knight #3: Modern Warfare 3 #2: Dragon Age 2 #1: GTA 4
Exvalos (7 months ago)
Breathe of the wild has little to no story, a bunch of bullshit mechanics and it is praised as one of the greatest games of all time with a damn 98 metacritic and yet it's not on this list.
Exvalos (7 months ago)
How is breathe of the wild not on here
tyrom T-p (7 months ago)
I don't agree with GTA
tyrom T-p (7 months ago)
First time I disliked a watchmojo video 😂
Ravus (7 months ago)
What's the worst you can do with Fable 3 ? drop it by 2 points 👎 same goes for gta iv which in my opinion has the best story & gameplay of the the series not mention it still holds up really well today.
Mr. Squirrel (7 months ago)
Arkham knight was dope
DrThomTheOriginal (7 months ago)
Your Arkham Knight description is so true. Quite a disappointing game.
Dark Master (8 months ago)
To me a game the is sold for $60 and has either loot boxes and/or microtransactions deserves a very bad rating.
i4c4eva (8 months ago)
I never believe reviews anyway because it's only one person's opinion I'd rather play the game myself and find out if it's good because a game I may find good someone else might not. For example I enjoyed genji days of the blade however every review I've seen and score system says it was horrendous
Letho Mori (8 months ago)
And where's Skyrim?
probotboyxxx (8 months ago)
Forgive me my fellow fans, but let me guess, "Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword?"
david barnett (8 months ago)
Good list. Fan boys cried and peed a little but good list.
TheKid Biscuit (8 months ago)
Disliked as soon as I seen GTA4. Y'all smoking crack
prophet dan (8 months ago)
batman arkham knight was the best in the series
Mohamed Samir (8 months ago)
gerty tk (8 months ago)
Red Dead Redemption?
Ballto Kenney (8 months ago)
Seeing Dragon Age 2 on here hurts my soul... I know the game has it's flaws (like the discombobulated story) but I still love it... IN fact, I was going to pirate it when it when it came out, then played the demo and said "this is way too fun, I have to buy it"
daniel hartness (8 months ago)
Skyward Sword should probably be number 1 here
the seal of orichalcos (8 months ago)
I have never agreed more with watchmojo.
Jakob Lund (8 months ago)
A lot of this has to do with expectations. Dragon Age 2 wasn't inherently an awful game. If it hadn't been a sequel to such an accomplished game, just a standalone release, then i don't think anyone would have minded the score. With GTA IV i think many gamers dislike it because it moved away from many of the core values of the GTA series. I've played all the major GTA titles and nr IV is without a doubt the one i like the least. Also the only one i didn't finish. I would probably have seen the game in a total different light had it not been called GTA.
miiles derpworth (8 months ago)
i thought fable 3 was good
Reovic Pace (8 months ago)
NBA 2K18, Forza Motorsport 7, Destiny 2???
Reovic Pace (8 months ago)
and Overwatch
counterfan90 (8 months ago)
GTA IV is a superb game, but underrated by ratkids what just wanna have fun crashing planes in the skyscrapers. But for anyone who wants a mature story settled in a great recreation of New York, this is The Game. For me, is even better than GTA V, a game that became boring at some times.
Code The Artist (8 months ago)
Fable is my favorite game, never played 3 but 1 & 2 we're fire imma keep it a buck 🔥🔥💯
K M (8 months ago)
wtf? "tired mechanics" how the fuck do you improve on a beat'em up?
Penguin Master 64 (8 months ago)
The first few I forgot if they were counting down games whose Metacritic Score are too high or if they were counting down my favorite games of all time. There were a lot of worse games that received higher scores than these, don't agree with this list.
Ketumile Maimane (8 months ago)
Can we get the top 10 most disliked WatchMojo videos this has to be in the top 3 period
Ketumile Maimane (8 months ago)
I immediately said WatchMojo are asses when they said "GTA IV doesn't deserve 98". Bruh that's literally one of the best games of all time. They most probably dickriding GTA V I swear
Rorke Zalyz (8 months ago)
Watchmojo is Cancer
Evan Plays (8 months ago)
Wow watchmojo is really running out of ideas, well their are at leasts other top 10 videos
Daniel Pierce (8 months ago)
Um...MW3 is pretty good. Also, multiplayer in that game was awesome especially on Infected and doing survival mode where you try to survive all the waves of computer enemies
Joe morgan (8 months ago)
Witcher 3!
25taylor91 (8 months ago)
Dragon Age 2 was amazing.
igsant br (8 months ago)
Top 1 Overrated YouTube Channel: Watchmojo!!!! Congrats guys!
goofed86 (8 months ago)
Nothing wrong with Fable 3 or GTA 4
goofed86 (8 months ago)
Zelda Breath Of the Wild and Mario Odyssey are far too high
Nick Corvello (8 months ago)
Im giving a like because theyre on the list, but Fable 3 and Dragon Age 2 should have been #1 and #2 respectfully. Fable 3 was complete utter shit as far as mechanics goes and was full of bugs that ruined even the "villager maker" website app's results. And Dragon Age 2 restricting the PC to human and removing player agency, alongside with Mass Effect 2 simplifying mechanics and focusing a more linear story, began the downfall of Bioware
reaper 21 (8 months ago)
fuck this bullshit mw3 was one of my favourite cod,s and gta 4 and arkaham knight were great games
marvel's greatest hero (8 months ago)
Cough half life 2 cough!
Eabalo2 (8 months ago)
I honestly think that Dragon Age 2 is amazing and even though it is not even close to being as good as the first (which in my opinion is basically the best game of all time) I still think the second deserves 80/100+.
Jere Lappalainen (8 months ago)
Gta v score is too high!! It should be 80 not 97. God i hate gta v. It sucks so bad!! Horrible story and main characters!
Kickass 101 (8 months ago)
I always liked the simplicity of fable
James Queralt (8 months ago)
So do people who comment on these actually watch the videos? “How dare they mention GTAIV, it was a great game, burn in hell WatchMojo” etc etc. Yes, they say it’s a great game, but say they’d stop short of calling it the second best game ever made, which is absolutely fair enough. I think the premise of the video has kinda flown over a lot of people’s heads.
BlackbohnsterGaming (8 months ago)
Arkham Knight deserves all the praise it can get! The Story was the best of the Arkham series, the batmobile was not as bad as everyone says it is (I had no problems controlling it) and the combat was great as always! Sorry, but Arkham should not be on the list.
Tremor Voorhees (8 months ago)
GTA IV is an amazing game it followed up to the episodes of Liberty City. The lost and damn and the ballad of gay tony
Frostbite38 (8 months ago)
I don't believe that you can knock gta IV for its graphics. When it came out it was leaps and miles better looking than any gta that came before it.
Ian Beckley (8 months ago)
I was expecting last of us at number 1
#SmurfsAreOppressed (8 months ago)
I hope GTA V is on this list.
GixusGaming (1 month ago)
calm down dude gta 4 make gta best top 1 because gta 4 is 3rd best game and gta 5 make gta best top 1 too because highly copied
Marlon Bascombe (8 months ago)
do not insult gta4!
Blade Runner 07 (8 months ago)
Arkham Knight and Modern Warfare 3 still deserves their Metacritic scores. Neither one intrude on the first twos score territory enough to warrant being on this list. Subjectively they were some of the most impressive games to come out in their respective years. They met the technical and story expectations laid down by their previous game, and their biggest fault was probably how similar (but improved) they are to their prequels. I think it's flawed logic that a game should be denied it's marks of greatness because it's subject or genre is common upon its release, or it's merely an improved iteration of its decidedly great predecessor. The actual score should be based on the piece itself and not on whether or not it's worth experiencing due to lack of innovation. I do agree GTAIV was rated crazy high considering the gameplay expectations coming out of San Andreas. You just didn't have the freedom or options you had in the previous game so it didn't feel like a good sequel but more of a simplified reboot. It didn't meet expectations but was still a great open-world game in it's own right. It just never felt like it earned the "IV" for not being as deep as the sequels to GTAIII were. Maybe they would have been better off just Calling it Grand Theft Auto as an official reboot.
Bartek Kubica (8 months ago)
Metacritic is like Oscars - no one really cares anymore.
AuronnBE (8 months ago)
We are talking about scores when these games were released. GTA IV was out of this world. I also disliked the driving, but damn, did that game have detail. A well deserved score in that year. Vice city also deserved 100% when released
BackwardsTongue (8 months ago)
Mw3 was the only cod i really loved.
Emin Eldarov (8 months ago)
Dragon Age Inquisition was much more overhyped.
João Carboni (8 months ago)
Fable 2 deserves 90!
RID 1 (8 months ago)
Gta 4 is a masterpiece
EpicNumber 79 (8 months ago)
GTA 4 deserves all the praise it got
Alec Oram (8 months ago)
SKYWARD SWORD People often say botw is overrated, but at least it deserves a majority of the praise. Skyward Sword is the worst 3d Zelda and received many unwarranted 10/10s
mousek801 Mousek801 (8 months ago)
Fable III humor? You joke...
Nene139 (8 months ago)
Gone home surely.
Hichnel Hichnel (8 months ago)
All the games deserves ther score
Jo S. (8 months ago)
Sorry but I don understand the DA2 hate. Like really. Its a great game. I liked it, Hawkes story, the more action gameplay and everything. I know many fans hated it but I liked some things from DA2 more like in 1st game. Some elements. And about the "re-use" environment from DA2. Many people have forgotten that DA2s story is set in a span of many years. Not in many areas. The game moves in time not in space.
zeth fox (8 months ago)
Deponia, the whole series.....deserves way way less of a score.
Andy B (8 months ago)
Destiny 2 should have made the list
Shownon (8 months ago)
Batman arkham Knight def deserved its score for the finale on PS4. Batmobile brought difference despite its wonky controls and Gotham is probably the best city ive seen in anygame given its diff areas. Batman arkham knight deserves no higher or less then an 87. That ending aswell? cmon...
skintightJJ (8 months ago)
Infinite warfares 77 metacritic is way to high, it deserves a spot on this list instead of mw3
Edward Majewski (8 months ago)
Why is breath of the wild not on this list?
Jey Kritov (8 months ago)
what about skyrim ?? people say its not better game than oblivion,but the score is above 90
Jenem7 (8 months ago)
I love how Watchmojo say Batman Arkham Knight got to high of a score even though watchmojo gave it number 7 on top 10 games of 2015
toastedsopas (8 months ago)
No Phantom Pain?
Binkus (8 months ago)
None of these are right

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.